Machiavelli in the Boardroom: Spotting Manipulative Leadership Before It Spreads
Share this article

Few management texts have aged as strangely as “The Prince”. Niccolò Machiavelli wrote it in the early 16th century, partly in response to powerful figures of his day such as Cesare Borgia and Pope Alexander VI, and his core argument was uncomfortable: being good and moral is not always enough to command respect and last, so leaders sometimes resort to underhand methods. Personnel Today recently revisited that legacy after hearing from Jane Gunn, founder and CEO of Barefoot Mediation, who warns that traits of this kind are still visible in leaders today, in an age where the modern textbook (open, collaborative, empathetic) sits uneasily beside management by personal whim.
What Machiavellianism Actually Means
Gunn describes Machiavellianism as a personality trait marked by cunning and manipulation, where self interest comes before everything else. It is one of three traits in what psychologists call the dark triad, alongside narcissism and psychopathy, and she is careful to keep them apart. Narcissistic traits involve a strong need for attention, validation, status or praise. Psychopathy shows up in callousness, reduced empathy and impulsivity. Machiavellianism, by contrast, is about manipulation and strategic behaviour in the pursuit of personal goals.
The Charm That Comes First
What makes these leaders hard to spot is that the early impression is often excellent. According to Gunn, they can seem charming, warm and welcoming at first, and then something shifts: they become difficult and demanding, and the people around them quickly feel unworthy or unprepared. She cites an analysis by Marbut, Harms and Credé linking Machiavellianism to undesirable leadership behaviours, and notes research suggesting that men high in the trait are more likely to fabricate information about themselves in job interviews. For anyone who hires senior people, that is worth pausing on.
Warning Signs in Everyday Behaviour
The signals Gunn lists are practical rather than psychological. Creating conflict or divisions within teams. Taking credit for someone else’s work. Shouting or blaming others when problems arise. A sense of superiority, relationships exploited for gain, and colleagues treated like children. Meetings offer another clue: a high scoring Machiavellian, she says, has a habit of hijacking the discussion, which is why a good chairperson matters.
Behaviours, Not Labels
Here the article offers a useful caution. Validated psychometric measures exist for research purposes, but Gunn says managers should not use them to assess colleagues. In most workplace situations, recognising recurring behaviours is more constructive than trying to name a personality type. She also notes that the trait often surfaces in politics, law, entrepreneurship, sales and sport, but that this does not make it an advantage. In other words, the question for an organisation is not who is a Machiavellian, but which behaviours it is prepared to tolerate, and for how long.
What It Means for Organisations
The lesson reaches well beyond one piece of research. When a company chooses a leader, a single polished interview says little about how that person treats colleagues under pressure. It is a theme close to Euren’s work in executive search and in the assessment and development of leaders: looking at behaviour across several situations, checking it through structured conversations and references, and giving boards and owners a fuller picture before a decision, not after. Charm is easy to see. Consistency is what a company has to learn to look for.